NPN Story: Savannah Dog Lady
I’ve seen some terrible houses in my day. As a cop in Watts back in the 90s, I saw some pretty
nasty crackhead houses and gangster crashpads. I’ve traveled to impoverished, third world
countries and seen some real squalor. From 2011 to 2013, I bought dozens of condos in the
Inland Empire (CA) and had some rough ones to fix up. But this REO we had in Savannah,
Georgia was definitely the worst one I’ve had to ever rehab.
I’m talking dog feces mixed with urine covering entire floors in bedrooms, from wall to wall. I’m talking about vegetation growing on the inside of the house because of broken windows and leaky ceilings. Smells so bad that a real estate agent I called to inspect the property wouldn’t even go in the front door. (That one cracked me up; he seemed a little thin skinned but when I walked the house myself a couple of months later, I could understand his reaction.)
Here’s the story:
I saw this note for sale with the property in Savannah, Georgia, for a second time in late 2016.
We had looked at it a year before but there were too many unknowns for us to pull the trigger.
We took another look at it and saw that it was a lot closer to foreclosure. The borrower
abandoned the property and the seller of the note had to go through a longer foreclosure
process because they couldn’t locate him (service by publication https://www.serve-
now.com/articles/512/what-is-service-by-publication). The house looked like it was an old,
Victorian haunted house, with the overgrown trees and vegetation, covered windows, faded
paint, and dilapidated siding.
I really wanted to get a peek inside and had a hard time finding someone who’d be willing to go up to the window and snap a couple of photos. I lucked out and one of my contractor buddies from my “day” job at the time said that his wife could drive by and check it out. She did and I was pleased at what I could see. There was some junk in there but everything else didn’t look too bad.
Our biggest problem was trying to get a good idea of value. All of our sources showed values
ranging from $50,000 to $280,000, which is something I wasn’t used to at the time and is a
definite red flag when you see that kind of variation. I called realtors in the area and I got a huge range of values from them, too, $125,000 to $300,000. This was odd.
Old Victorian in Savannah, Georgia The more I looked into it, I came to the realization that Savannah was one of those markets with huge diversity in real estate that makes comping (valuing) properties very difficult, even for the professionals. The neighborhoods there can and do change drastically from block to block. You could have a historical, perfectly restored Victorian style home worth a million bucks on one side of the street and then have a rundown, crackhouse, 5 or 6 houses down worth $50k.
If you’re doing your values strictly by square footage and room count, you’re at a huge
disadvantage and will make mistakes all day long when valuing a property in downtown
Savannah. Even locals will make mistakes and you really have to have a good handle on the
neighborhood, trends, and what’s happening locally. (Note to investors: You can have a
tremendous advantage in real estate markets that have this diversity in real estate values that
require local knowledge when you know the market better than everyone else does.)
Although there was this huge variation in possible property value, we felt confident that it was
actually worth $225k to $275k. Still a huge range but worth the risk at the right price. We went back and forth with the seller and they agreed to sell the loan for $70k.
Licenses? We Don’t Need No Stinking Licenses! Uh, Yes, You Do.
The loan foreclosed during interim servicing so we got it back as an REO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_estate_owned, 45 days after we bought the loan. This was a stroke of luck not only because we got the property back right away but because we found out after we bought it that the state of Georgia was very strict about requiring note buyers to have their lenders license. Georgia requires that investors that buy notes on the secondary market, like us, are required to have lenders licenses and are active in finding unlicensed buyers of notes and forcing them to get rid of their notes. We talked to at least one note broker who told of a client of his who just purchased a portfolio of loans only to have to turn around and sell the whole thing at a loss because the state found out and forced the sale.
Thank God we got lucky and this was now an REO. For the future, we made it a point to make
sure we had the right licenses before we bought any loans in a particular state.
Now that the house was ours, I had to find boots on the ground. One method to flip houses from across the country is to find a real estate agent to manage the rehab, get contractor bids, make sure the lawn gets cut, and to turn on the utilities in exchange for listing the property and earning a commission upon selling it.
I called quite a few agents before I found one with great reviews on Yelp! Yelp.com that agreed to go have a locksmith change the locks and inspect the property. This was the poor guy who took one look at the inside and basically said in a southern accent, “Hail, no!” Some realtors like more polished listings but, to be fair, this place was disgusting.
I found my “boots on the ground” through Biggerpockets.com. I posted about needing to find
someone to help me out and a newbie investor, local to Savannah, answered my call. She got a HUGE amount of experience and some pay and I got a local project manager.
Disaster? OMG We very rarely see any of our properties in person but this one had its challenges. I flew out from California and this is what I saw:
I wasn’t exaggerating. Dog feces, urine, wild vegetation growing inside and outside the house. Abandoned RV in the backyard. We halfway expected to find a dead body once the backyard was cleaned up.
Poor, Poor Dogs….
From what we could see, someone had built wooden dog kennels in the two upstairs bedrooms. There were a couple of kennels downstairs in the bathroom and closet as well. It broke my heart to see the inside doors of these kennels with claw, scratch, and bite marks from what must’ve been desperate animals trying to get out. The corners of the doors had been chewed back. It was awful.
One of the creepiest things was a chain tied to a high branch of a tree in the backyard.
Especially given that we were in the South, it felt very strange.
As a cop in Watts, I’d seen a lot of cruelty to animals, usually gangsters raising dogs for fighting. I suspected that this house had been used for that purpose. I thought that the kennels, the poor conditions, were all consistent with some gang or hoodlum using this abandoned, vacant house to raise fighting dogs.
While my PM and I were waiting outside the house for a contractor, a neighbor approached us. She told us that the house had been occupied by a mentally disturbed dog lady. She took in all of the neighborhood strays. She didn’t turn away a single one. The last that the neighbor heard, the woman left to go out to the “country,” some remote part of Georgia away from everything else.
I felt better that I was wrong about the gangster dog fighting but it wasn’t much comfort to think of a poor, deranged woman taking care of these animals, given what I’d seen….
It took 3 months to clean up and fix the mess. If you didn’t know the history, you would never
have guessed what was there before. Cleaning up the initial mess and landscaping cost a few
thousand bucks but made the place look 10 times better.
Some more work and it shined up like a new penny. Here are some before and after pics:
Things I learned:
Do the extra work to get your values right. You mitigate your risk and open yourself to bigger profits when it’s even more valuable than you think.
Check the state you want to buy your note in to make sure you have the proper licenses.
When you’re willing to take on additional risk (valuation risk, unknown extent of When you’re willing to take on additional risk (valuation risk, unknown extent of rehab with older building), make sure you get enough of a discount when buying. Get paid to deal with problems that others don’t want.
If dog feces and urine aren’t your thing, leave it to someone like me who’ll put up with that shit.
When you’re dealing with older buildings (especially in historical district), include a generous cushion in your repair estimates. Once you start opening up walls, you’ll find additional problems that need to be addressed.
I love Savannah, Georgia for many things but it remains a place of great opportunity for
the fix and flip investor willing to get to know its neighborhoods.
Purchase Price: $70,000
Total Cost Basis: $159,483 (repair cost about $80,000)
Net Sales Price: $251,783
Net Profit: $92,300
Days Held: 283
Return on Investment (ROI): 57.6%
Annualized ROI: 74.3%
Andy Mirza is the Chief Operating Officer for Coastline Capital Fund Management, LLC, a
company that creates and manages funds that buy, sell, and liquidate residential non-
performing notes (defaulted mortgages).